Guidelines for Assessment Marketing DAO Proposals

Resources

Link to Original Google Docs - Guidelines for Assessment (Latest Version)

Marketing DAO Relaunch Announcement - Gov Forum

Application Form

Types of Content (Slides)

Marketing DAO Handbook

How to Use this Guide

These guidelines are split into two categories:

  • General Questions that we would ask every project, based largely on the strategic goals from the NEAR Foundation.
  • Vertical specific guidelines. These are meant to serve as additional guidance, namely, what sort of questions may we ask to determine whether the General Questions criteria is being met for this specific type of content.

Guidelines have been derived from reviewing performance, challenges and lessons from the past year of operations and ongoing conversations with the NEAR Foundation and the community.

These guidelines are expected to change as the ecosystem evolves. If your project does not fall squarely within these guidelines, contact us so we can discuss.

General Questions

These questions are around establishing the Fundamental Alignment required between projects seeking funding and what the Community Fund is able to fund.

Categories are deliberately broad as we do not want to restrict any applicants. It is up to each project to demonstrate they meet the fundamental alignment threshold.

Will this project help develop a thriving ecosystem of high quality projects?

  • NF KPIs to track progress:

    1. New Projects
    2. Active Apps
    3. Weekly Active DAOs
    4. Active Wallets
    5. Increase overall education, reach, and drive positive traction in the market
  • Assessment by M DAO:

    1. Does this project create an inspiring, vibrant community that makes people want to join?
    2. Does the project promote core qualities, characteristics, and progress about NEAR that can educate and inspire others to take action?
    3. Is this project providing value to other builders and projects in the ecosystem in ways in which it accelerates their growth?

Will this project result in an entry point for Web3 talent?

  • NF KPIs:

    1. Active Developers / Builders
    2. Number of Community Members
  • Assessment by DAO:

    1. Distribution Channel; is the team well placed to reach new audiences?
    2. Does the team have enough depth of knowledge about NEAR, what’s happening in the ecosystem, other unique insights and valuable knowledge;
    3. Is the project or team, able to communicate clearly and concisely complex concepts to new audiences?
    4. What would potential developers/builders think/feel if they come in contact with content?
      4.1 Acceptable: that NEAR is a lea- der in blockchain technology, professionalism, inspired to build, curious to learn more, etc.
      4.2 Unacceptable: Scammy, pump and dump, vapourware.

Is this project of reasonable quality to receive capital?

  • NF KPIs

    1. Quality work
    2. Fair price for the work
  • Assessment by DAO

    1. Would a third party pay for the work at the quoted price?
    2. Is the price quoted aligned with the industry standards?
    3. Is the work generating more value to the ecosystem than it is extracting?

Vertical Specific - Content

Content and creativity comes in all shapes and forms.

We do not want to place any constraints on the ways in which you may communicate and amplify key messaging about NEAR.

Below are some of the categories and the set of criteria we will take into consideration to assess each. It is expected that this criteria will continue to evolve over time.

Writing

  • Subject Matter - is the core substance of the writing about NEAR Ecosystem?
  • Potential impact of content on readers.
  • Who is the target audience?
  • How are you going to reach that audience?
  • Previous Work - quality writing, established audience.
  • Depth of understanding and insight on the topic.
  • Uniqueness of work (differentiated)
    • Is the creator providing adding to public discourse;
    • Independent insights, analysis, explanations
  • Is the writing being done in collaboration with other projects?
    • We are more likely to fund work produced as a direct response to ecosystem needs. i.e. you are in contact with other ecosystem players and creating high quality content for them.

Video

  • Subject Matter - is the core substance of the writing about NEAR Ecosystem?
  • Depth of understanding and insight on the topic.
  • Uniqueness of work (differentiated.)
  • Previous Work - quality writing, established audience.
  • Production and sophistication
    • Leverages tooling available to produce high quality content relevant to an audience
      • Editing, subtitles, music, visual effects, etc.

Visual / Design

  • Subject Matter - is the core substance of the content about NEAR Ecosystem?
  • Is the design visually appealing, easy to understand, without typos.
  • Does the visual work link or refer to other sources where people can learn more.
  • Custom design or templates?
    • Both are acceptable, but we acknowledge that they require different resources and have different costs.
  • Is the visual design able to capture complex subjects, trending topics, and other key areas of interest in a simple and concise manner that is easy for anyone scrolling to understand?
  • Is the content widely shared in such a way that other members of the ecosystem rely on it to communicate and amplify key messaging around NEAR.

Podcasts

  • Subject Matter - is the core substance of the content about NEAR Ecosystem?
  • Examples of previous work. Not able to fund brand new ventures.
  • Quality of Guests
  • Is the podcast building a Brand?
    • Visual Design
    • Naming
    • Presence on Social Media
    • Anything that elevates and cements NEAR presence in the world as a result of the podcast succeeding.
  • Is the podcast widely distributed and available on major podcasting platforms?
  • Is the podcast a suitable avenue for projects in the ecosystem to share their progress, reach new audiences?

Social Media

Out of Scope

In Scope - Content and Distribution

There’s a strong overlap between the Social Media vertical guidelines and the Content specific guidelines listed above.

We are all on social media, a lot. So what do we look for in Social Media applicants?

  • Does the Social Media presence amplify and communicate things in such a way that creates a vibrant, welcoming community (the opposite of silence, ghost chains).
  • Is the content generating organic engagement? Reach
  • Is the Social Media account able to build brand recognition?
  • Are the Social Media assets embedded in the community, well known and acknowledged as active contributors
  • Ability to reach audiences across a range of platforms, blockchains, grow audience
  • Ability to take existing content and create platform specific content that demonstrate skills and mastery on that platform (i.e. Taking content from Blog post to generate short videos or content from Twitter Spaces to generate blog posts, etc.)
  • Does the content and social media presence elevates the perception of NEAR across other crypto ecosystem players?
  • Content optimized for engagement, SEO, Calls to Action, where applicable.

Questions?

We hope you find the guidelines above useful. We welcome feedback and discussion on the governance forum, and you can reach out to us directly for specific queries relating to your project.

Email - marketingdao@proton.me
Twitter - https://twitter.com/MarketingDAOers

Or DM any of the Marketing DAO Council Members @Dacha @so608 @cryptocredit @Klint

LFG :mechanical_arm:

29 Likes
[Approved] Near NFT Podcast Show
[Approved] December 2022 Funding for Marketing to create content and introduce new users to the NEAR ecosystem
[Closed] Starting Web3 Club on NEAR
[Closed] Funding For the NEAR French Community for the next 3 months ( October , November and December )
[Approvedl] December Near Brasil webducation 3.0
[Closed] Promotion in youtube
[Closed] Near Turkiye Community October and November)l
[Closed] November - December 2022 Social Media Content Creation NEAR x CryptoSofa
[APPROVED] SHITZU'S crossword and engagement activities to promote the entire NEAR ecosystem
[Closed] Q4 Marketing Budget for Nomen Market - The Wallet & Smart Contract Marketplace for NEAR
[Approved] NEAR at NIGHT Twitter Spaces - Monthly Funding Request (November)
[Closed] Near Coverage for November 2022
[Closed] November/December Creating content about the NEAR ecosystem
[CLOSED] Thespians DAO December 2022 - January 2023 Content Creations and Social Media Management Funding Request
[Closed] NEAR grassroot sports community in the month of december, 2022
[APPROVED] NEAR Turkey December / January 2023
[Approved] NEAR YouTube Social Media Promotion Budget Sookast
[APPROVED] NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2022 Social Media Management/Marketing budget for De3Verse
[CLOSED] November/December 2022 Social Media Management + Marketing & Communication budget for Incubadora DAO
[Approved] November 2022 NEAR Media & News Guild Social Media Moderation Budget
[Closed] Near Digital Fashion Podcast Series Funding Request For December2022 and January2023
[Closed] RISING THINKS Initiative: Content and Social Media Proposal
[Closed] December 2022- January 2023 Social media content creation and management budget for C1 Guild
[Approved] Budget for November - December to create media content on YouTube channel
[CLOSED] Marketing OctopodeDAO November / December 2022
[Approved] December 2022 - Content & Social Media | Near Insider
[CLOSED] Ready Layer One presents "Flex-A-Tech" NEAR Hackathons
[Closed] Twitter spaces, social media bounty and content creation in patois December 2022 /January 2023
[Approved] Near Native Community Guild (Content + Translations + Activities) November 2022Approved
NEAR Foundation Twitter Spaces on NDC - January 12 - Recap
[Closed] Marketing Grant for Beta Testers on our NEAR Ad server Pr3sence
[Closed] NEAR Philippines December 2022 - January 2023 Initiative
[CLOSED] PureCube Marketing Funding
[Approvedl] December Near Brasil webducation 3.0
[Closed] DECEMBER and JANUARY contents and social media management -NEAR Health Guild
[CLOSED] Crypto for dummies
[Approved, $3150] ODDio3 - Marketing DAO Proposal
[Closed] campaign cohort circle onboarding NEAR for AjoDAO
(Closed) youtube content creation and social media advertising
[CLOSED] DECEMBER 2022 Creating content about the NEAR ecosystem (Youtube video series)
[Closed] CryptoTVplus X NEAR - Marketing DAO Proposal
[Closed] January 2023
[Closed] Near Coverage for November 2022
[Closed] January 2023 - Content, Social Media, Support Project & AMA | Near Insider Guild
[APPROVED] SHITZU'S crossword and engagement activities to promote the entire NEAR ecosystem
[Closed] DECEMBER and JANUARY contents and social media management -NEAR Health Guild
[Closed] Starting Web3 Club on NEAR
[Closed] Near Web3 Content Creation & Social Media Management December 2022 / January 2023
[CLOSED] Crypto for dummies
[Closed] NEAR Philippines December 2022 - January 2023 Initiative
[CLOSED] PureCube Marketing Funding
[Approved] Marketing DAO council remuneration - revised for relaunch
[Approved] Funding For the NEAR French Community for December
[Closed] Onboarding Devs into the near Ecosystem and helping non technical Founder Navigate their Way in the Near Ecosystem
[APPROVED] November 2022 - Social media, Content Website Hub, High Active&antibot Quality of AMAs - Nearity
[Approved] December 2022 - Social media, Content Website Hub, High Active&antibot Quality of AMAs - Nearity
The fall of the last guild standing. Stars Guild is dead! :dizzy:
[PROPOSAL] NEAR Malaysia funding Dec'22 to Feb'23
[Closed] Near Web3 Content Creation & Social Media Management December 2022 / January 2023
[Approved] Incrypted news media support and Portfolio Battle activity
[CLOSED] Near For Hausa Community
[Closed] NEAR FA Guild ( January - February )
[Closed] Onboarding on air personalities and hosting near radio talk show
[Closed] Onboarding & Educating Hairstylist in the potential of using NFT/Metaverse
[PROPOSAL] ALPHAFLEXHUB| social media content creation for NEAR ecosystem
[Closed] Media content creation in my telegram channel
[Closed] Media for NEAR by CUDO DAO
[Approved] Feb 2023 Social media budget for NEAR VIETNAM
[Closed] Budget for December - January 2023 to create media content on YouTube channel
[Approved] WOTAverseDAO - MarketingDAO Funding - Q1 2023 - Marketing Campaign for WOTA (World of the Abyss )
[APPROVED] TENAMINT | Social Media & Content Creation Budget for Community Growth Campaign
[Approved] Meet the Latino builders of NEAR | Diffusion of NEAR content in Spanish
[Proposal] Feb 2023 - Social Media, Support Projects & AMA | Near Insider
[CLOSED] Onboard Black Gold Nation to NEAR, Satori, and AstroDAO to Marketing DAO
[PROPOSAL] Poker on NEAR 2023

Can sumbission guide also be updated?

Filled the form, took like 4 hours to do so. Think that in proposal these questions should be answered before.

Maybe can recommend to add a field of email and/or telegram so that feedback about sumbission can be sent to application submitters. :slight_smile:

3 Likes

@Presence check it :point_up_2:

1 Like

Hello, you can come up with a form that is simpler, more convenient and more specific, and not sky-high. Thank you for your attention

1 Like

Good evening.
With your new criterion, you move people away from decentralization, your restrictions are centralized. How many active wallets do I need? How to understand the activity of wallets? Thank you

These criteria are so complex to reach out, and what about the current projects that are running on NEAR protocol and doesn’t meet the desire new criteria ,what about them.
Thank you :bowing_man:

Hi.
Hello. Does this innovation concern all participants? First of all, a question to @jack , do you yourself meet this criteria? Please show me your completed document! Now the question to the @marketingdao-council who are recipients of monthly grants, where are your completed samples? @satojandro , you are actively starting to promote new points for grants, and how did your YouTube channel funding happen? Your telegram channel is not active. Who approved the grant to you in NF? Why didn’t you, like all the participants, write a proposal on the forum? Where are your reports? There are too many unanswered questions. If you want to change the world for the better, start with yourself.
Thx :slight_smile:

5 Likes

My application was submitted via the previous form before this was announced and I was unaware of the new form. I copy/pasted everything as was indicated at the end of the form to a Gov forum post. I can share it here if needed, but I tagged the councils there already.

Do I need to re-submit?

3 Likes

Let me know when you understand that everything is getting to be f*cking ImpoSsible.

We’re about to enter the impossible moment with the platform.
funny enough, at the end of the day, all criteria are not even the solution,
well, good enough as it will favour the @marketingdao-council team more.

5billion imaginary adoption through @marketingdao-council impossible criteria.

Im sure if they are not the councils, the would come to write out the impossibilities.

1 Like

Im sorry, they wont this question, they would locked this thread soon cos they dont like when we remind them of their personal fails.

1 Like

I have been trying to fill the application form but its not just loading from my end.

Is there another way one could access it please?

@raissalaban @PatriciaB , @Narau @SarmanhoMairy

Read this, please!

Thanks

2 Likes