Damn , 13k dollars for Reddit channel where 70% of links
and reposts . So weird.
Just my proposal. I think it’s a great idea .
First-of-all, I need analyze all proposals, see how others councils work.
We have already discussed the Reddit payouts, at least three times.
Don’t think this is too relevant. We wanted designs and went to the design Guild?
This one was discussed on the forum? There was plenty of time for anyone and everyone to comment.
Not only one. I’m preparing list of all proposals. You’re one of most active council here.
It will be particular topic about Reddit team compares their work and grantees work from OWS, why they got $10000 vs $100 for same work in OWS, etc
As a new council , today I reviewed all 100 proposals in Marketing DAO on the forum
1)Nobody work with fixing categories for proposals , for instance Members can wrongly choose “Marketing” tag instead of “Marketing DAO”. Dear @David_NEAR I need mod/admin access to fix it.
2)Nobody help to Community Members choose right category in they made mistakes;
3)Only 5 of 45 grantees provided their reports after marketing activities.
I am preparing full information about it.
4)Over 50 proposals are waiting for some actions (decisions , be marked as “Declined” or anything) up to 179 days.
5)Here is information about transparency , discussion on public ( since Sep 1st when 2 councils from Community started work)
Couldn’t find even one proposal where all councils commented it together.
6)Some proposals were approved without any public discussions
and All other Reddit proposals
7)In my next report I am gonna show how councils voted in Sputnik and Astro DAO
PS @David_NEAR did you get money for your proposal ?
Dear @Grace , why Marketing DAO has limited funds? Why Marketing DAO like a Business DAO, Ecosystem DAO isn’t able to have sufficient fund for work?
Many weird proposals like 14k dollars https://app.astrodao.com/dao/marketing.sputnik-dao.near/proposals/marketing.sputnik-dao.near-36 for Reddit channel where 70% links and re-posts.
We could approve
15 other proposals for New Community Members instead of one Reddit channel. If it so valuable for NF why you can funding it directly?
Please, let me know if you find mistakes. Was not easy reviewed 100 proposals.
Great job! We are waiting for the continuation of the investigation.
You should already have this. I’m actively doing this, as are the Sherpas and other Council Members.
They receive a DM.
Yes, it’s on the old SputnikDAO.
We have regular monthly funding. The coffer isn’t unlimited and we need to deploy NEAR in a responsible manner
This was added yesterday
Amazing work, @Dacha!
Yes, cool. I’m going to put right tags for proposals.
Also thinking about new categories
[Pending since %Date , briefly reason]
Good evening , Thank You!
Awesome work @Dacha So much research and input in few days. Keep up the good work.
Week 52 continue
- Taking with Marketing DAO grantees about current issues. Main is timing and lack of transparency,
- Working with new proposals.
- And fixing fixing fixing tags. Why councils don’t put attention on proposals tags?
I agree that it is necessary to share information with people more often, and also to strengthen control over the allocation of funds.
@Dacha I really love the work you are putting in and am sure with people like you, efficiency can be close to ideal
Good evening, spent my weekends for detailed reviews of all proposals in Marketing DAO
What we have:
Overall Marketing DAO in 2021
- Received over 110 proposals, more than 65 approved,
- Distributed 35 000 + N through Sputnik and Astro DAO,
- Reviewed over 34 reports.
Most active in proposals discussion and voting is @David_NEAR
Marketing DAO payments per guild (leaders + guilds wallets) and community members.
Sue.near Reddit stands on 1st place , over 20% of all Marketing DAO paymets.
Over 44 proposals still waiting up to 185 days for any actions
Fixed tons of tags and titles.
- Probably, need to update our instucton , add some new titles
[Delay, sicnce $date, reason]
It definetly will help to our grantees understand status of their proposals.
- Some members using wrong tags for reports, it makes finding process very difficult. I think we need to update our guidance, and ask people to do reports at the same thread with proposal.
Work with reports.
Proposal + no discussions + no reports
And couple worlds about Equal access:
In December Marketing DAO got 30 proposals, approved only 5 (4 of them supervised by NF people).
We need to clone @Dacha
This massive input is really exceptional.
You’re doing great @Dacha
This kind of energy and work rate is why NEAR will always remain at the top.
Just a great job! There was a great lack of such systematization. From the Kitchen Guild side, I fully approve of such activities! This will help make the community more open and professional! Thank you @Dacha