[PROPOSAL] Family DAO Project Funding (march)

[williamx]

Hi @bgem, since your proposal has moved to Community DAO, here are some of my thoughts:

@bgem

$400 for 4 families

Total: $1600

We are giving them to put happiness in their home, so many families needs this support to be very honest, no one would do it if the near foundation ain’t gonna do it. this will forever put the happiness in their family.

This is sweet, but it is not a compelling purpose to spend money on the minor to get a chance to onboard them. We invest in talents/potential projects/marketing campaigns to attract people with interests & share the same vision. My questions:

• Families may need support in terms of money, but what do they do after being onboarded?

@bgem

This will give us chance to educate them about the whole NEAR ECOSYSTEM

This requires further resources, including people, money & time, which is not mentioned in the current proposal => Because you claimed this is not charity work, we definitely have to consider is it worth spending.

@bgem

They will also share secrets in their family linage to us, which we can mint and sell as NFTs with their NEAR wallet.

For me, it is not a nice thing to get their secrets to be minted as NFT and be commercialized. Let alone who is your target audience to sell those NFT? Also, the chance of their NFT being bought by someone is not guaranteed.

It’s a no from me at the being time due to the following reasons:

1. Metrics to measures success is not clear
2. Since this is not charity work, the amount requested is not aligned with the outcome.

@bgem

We will use the avenue to also onboard their children many of them have children for as old as even 25yrs old but they are just poor…

@bgem

To be honest, the vision behind of the family Dao is to empower, support and put smiles on poor families faces.

Since your target is poor families, providing them with enough knowledge & skills to understand & engage with the Near ecosystem (onboarding them) is not a practical purpose of this sole proposal.