Hello, @Sofia_Alum @shreyas @chronear @vrdoingthings @cloudmex-alan @Cristian
I had tested the platform in previous days and I left some suggestions on February 16, 2022 using the Feedback button (orange). I imagine this works, right?
OK. Here is an exact copy of what I said in that feedback, and I also add some additional words:
- To see all the Guild’s, I have to hit “Show more” several times until I find the guild of interest. That is not efficient to search [for a Guild] within this portal, which will eventually grow as https://nearguilds.com/ already has. To search for a specific Guild, you should add a search button based on keywords or tags (e.g., “Search by title …” or some filter tool). To define these keywords, some rules could be created to standardize their creation within each Guild (e.g., Country, type of products, OWS, how it connects to the real world, NFT, DApp, DeFi, etc.).
Commenting this with @FritzWorm on the Discord, he has clarified to me that the proposal of point 1 is very good, but that the Guilds are not defined by NFT DaPP etc. My example has been bad, sorry!. We agree that some categories/tags must be defined, such as: MARKETING, DESIGN, CREATIVES, DEVELOPMENT, LEGAL, … Solving this is very important, because it would be an advance to quickly find the Guild of interest. The other existing portal I mentioned isn’t bad, with that one I found out about Guilds I didn’t know existed when I discovered it, but suffers from this, the same issue as the newer one.
Note that what I am saying extends from the original proposal, the suggestion of Aaron:
Another site with similar information is https://near.org/guilds/ (incomplete in my opinion !). One of the three must prevail. If the new site is supposed to replace the others, then to avoid confusion/redundancy the others should be removed. Any call from another site must link to the new one.
- I have tried to join NEAR Hispano [I also did it for OWS !], with the “JOIN US” button, then it says “Loading”, “Validiting” (what it is?) and the result is “Joined”. Ok great! Question: (a) What happens next, if I am united and where within NEAR Hispano? (b) Let’s suppose that I want to leave, that is, disjoin because I made the wrong Guild [It is not my case, I am happy with NEAR Hispano !]. I hit the button by accident, that can happen! What options do I have through this portal? How do I get out?
Forget point 2.a, I already understood what happens. Great, this is “On chain Guilds”, he he. But I’m going to point 2.b., it’s important to have the disjoin option, it can be sad if we have been inactive for a long time within a guild, rather than joining by mistake.
Thank you very much, I am very amazed that you are doing these things. I hope that my proposals have been to your liking. 
The portal will be very useful. 